Best Soft Plastic Lure Making Kit – Top 5 Picks & Review

Imagine this: you’re out on the water, casting your line, and you feel that tell-tale tug. The fish is on! But what if you could have a hand in creating the very lure that enticed that bite? Making your own soft plastic fishing lures is a rewarding hobby, but diving into the world of lure-making kits can feel like navigating a tangled fishing line. It’s easy to get overwhelmed by all the different components, colors, and molds available. You want a kit that’s easy to use, offers great results, and doesn’t break the bank, but finding that perfect balance can be tricky.

That’s where this guide comes in. We’re going to cut through the confusion and help you understand exactly what makes a great soft plastic lure making kit. By the end of this post, you’ll know what features to look for, what to avoid, and how to choose a kit that will have you crafting custom lures like a pro. Get ready to unlock a new level of fishing enjoyment and impress your fellow anglers with your homemade creations.

Our Top 5 Soft Plastic Lure Making Kit Recommendations at a Glance

Top 5 Soft Plastic Lure Making Kit Detailed Reviews

1. Man Crates

Man Crates, Lure Making Kit – Soft Plastic Fishing Lure Making Kit with Molds, Plastisol, Color, Glitter & Scent – DIY Fishing Lure Set – Great Gift for Men & Fishermen

Rating: 9.3/10

The Man Crates Soft Plastic Fishing Lure Making Kit lets you craft custom lures that fish can’t resist. Say goodbye to boring, mass-produced lures. This kit empowers you to create unique designs that will help you reel in more fish. It’s a fantastic way to personalize your fishing gear and impress your buddies.

What We Like:

  • You get three exclusive molds: Crawdaddy, Mudbug, and Worm. These shapes are designed to attract fish.
  • The kit includes everything you need: plastisol, coloring, glitter, and scent. A Fire-King measuring cup is also included.
  • Easy-to-follow, step-by-step Lure Making Guide helps you create pro-level lures.
  • These handcrafted lures work great for bass, trout, catfish, and many other fish.
  • It makes an awesome gift for any fisherman in your life.

What Could Be Improved:

  • The kit could benefit from a wider variety of mold shapes for even more customization options.
  • While the included colors are good, a larger palette would allow for more advanced lure designs.

This DIY lure making kit is a fun and rewarding experience. It’s the perfect way to upgrade your fishing game and create a memorable gift.

2. Polysol Polymers Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 142 Soft Formula – Fishing Soft Plastic Lure – 1 Piece

Polysol Polymers Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol - 142 Soft Formula - Fishing Soft Plastic Lure - 1 Piece

Rating: 8.7/10

This Polysol Polymers Bait Plastics Premium Lure Plastisol – 142 Soft Formula – Fishing Soft Plastic Lure – 1 Piece is a top-notch choice for anglers looking to create their own soft plastic fishing lures. It’s designed to give you excellent results every time you use it.

What We Like:

  • The plastisol offers excellent clarity, meaning your homemade lures will look incredibly realistic and appealing to fish.
  • It’s formulated to be non-yellowing and non-scorching, so your lures will keep their vibrant colors and won’t degrade over time, even with repeated use or exposure to the sun.
  • You won’t find any hard pack with this product; it stays consistently soft and pliable, making it easy to pour and work with.
  • The low odor feature is a big plus for anyone who spends a lot of time working with lure-making materials. It makes the process much more enjoyable and less intrusive.

What Could Be Improved:

  • While the 142 Soft Formula is fantastic for many applications, some very specialized lure designs might benefit from a slightly different firmness option.
  • Availability can sometimes be a factor, as high-quality materials tend to be popular among serious lure makers.

This Polysol Polymers plastisol is a fantastic material for creating custom soft plastic fishing lures. It delivers on its promises, making your lure-making projects successful and enjoyable.

3. Generic The Golden Grub Lure Co. – Super Starter Set – Swimbait Kit

Generic The Golden Grub Lure Co. - Super Starter Set - Swimbait Kit

Rating: 9.1/10

The Generic The Golden Grub Lure Co. – Super Starter Set – Swimbait Kit is a fantastic way to get into fishing or add to your existing tackle box. This kit is designed to make fishing fun and simple, even for beginners. You get a variety of realistic-looking swimbaits that attract fish. It’s a great way to start catching more fish without a huge expense.

What We Like:

  • Fun & Easy to Learn: The swimbaits are designed to be easy to use. Even if you’re new to fishing, you can quickly learn how to make them work. You’ll be casting and retrieving like a pro in no time.
  • Saves you Money: This starter set gives you a good collection of lures at a lower price than buying them all separately. It’s a smart way to get a lot of value for your money. You don’t need to break the bank to get started.
  • Great Gift Idea for Fishermen: Looking for a gift for the angler in your life? This kit is a winner. It’s something they can use right away and will appreciate. It’s thoughtful and practical.

What Could Be Improved:

  • Limited Color Variety: While the shapes are good, the kit could benefit from a wider range of colors to match different water conditions and fish preferences.
  • Durability of Hooks: Some of the included hooks might not be the sharpest or strongest. For serious anglers targeting larger fish, upgrading the hooks might be necessary.

This Super Starter Set is an excellent value for anyone wanting to enjoy fishing more. It’s a practical and enjoyable addition to any fishing trip.

4. Smedioks Premium Soft Plastiс Mold Lure Making Injection Molds Fishing Lures 3 Cavity Yama Senko 5”

Rating: 8.8/10

Want to make your own fishing lures that look like the pros make? The Smedioks Premium Soft Plastic Mold lets you do just that! You can create three 5-inch Yama Senko style lures at a time, right from your home. Imagine catching more fish with lures you made yourself!

What We Like:

  • You can make professional-looking lures without leaving your house.
  • You get to pick the colors and smells you want for your lures. This means you can make lures perfect for different kinds of fish and water.
  • Making your own lures saves you a lot of money compared to buying them.
  • The mold is made of strong plastic, so it will last a long time, even with lots of use.
  • It’s super easy to use, whether you’ve been fishing for years or are just starting out.

What Could Be Improved:

  • The mold only makes one specific style of lure.
  • It requires separate plastic and pouring equipment, which is an extra cost and step.

This mold is a fantastic way for any angler to make their own custom lures and save money. You’ll be reeling in fish with your homemade creations in no time!

5. Generic The Golden Grub Lure Co. – Super Starter Set – Mr. Twitchy Kit

Generic The Golden Grub Lure Co. - Super Starter Set - Mr. Twitchy Kit

Rating: 9.5/10

The Generic The Golden Grub Lure Co. – Super Starter Set – Mr. Twitchy Kit is a fantastic way to get into bass fishing or add to your existing tackle box. This kit is designed to make learning how to fish fun and simple for everyone. It includes everything you need to start casting and catching those elusive bass.

What We Like:

  • It’s really fun and easy to learn how to use.
  • You’ll save money on bait since these lures are reusable.
  • It makes a great gift for any bass fisherman you know.
  • The lures are designed to attract bass effectively.
  • The kit comes with a good variety of lures to try.

What Could Be Improved:

  • More detailed instructions could be helpful for absolute beginners.
  • A small storage container for the lures would be a nice addition.
  • Some users might want even more lure types in a larger kit.

This Mr. Twitchy Kit is an excellent value and a smart choice for anglers of all skill levels. Grab yours and start reeling in some big ones!

Your Guide to Crafting Awesome Soft Plastic Lures

Ever wanted to make your own fishing lures? It’s a fun hobby! You can create lures that catch fish. A soft plastic lure making kit is your ticket to this exciting world. This guide will help you pick the best kit. We’ll look at what makes a kit great and what materials you need.

1. Key Features to Look For in a Kit

When you shop for a kit, check out these important things:

  • Variety of Colors: Good kits have many colors. You can make lures that look like real bait.
  • Mold Designs: Kits often come with molds. Look for different shapes like worms, grubs, or swimbaits.
  • Quality Plastic: The plastic should be soft but strong. It shouldn’t tear easily.
  • Additives: Some kits include scent or glitter. These can make your lures more attractive to fish.
  • Safety Gear: Making lures involves hot plastic. Make sure the kit includes gloves and maybe eye protection.
  • Clear Instructions: Easy-to-follow steps are a must, especially for beginners.

2. Important Materials You’ll Find (or Need)

A lure making kit usually has these core items:

  • Plastic Pellets/Liquid Plastic: This is the main ingredient for your lures. It melts to create the shape.
  • Colorants: These are special dyes that give your plastic its color.
  • Molds: These are the forms that give your lure its shape. They can be made of metal or plastic.
  • Measuring Tools: You’ll need cups and spoons to measure the plastic and colorants accurately.
  • Stirring Sticks: To mix the plastic and colors together.

You might need to buy a few extra things:

  • Heat Source: A microwave or a specialized pouring pot is needed to melt the plastic.
  • Pouring Cups: Heat-resistant cups for melting and pouring.
  • Safety Gloves: To protect your hands from hot plastic.

3. Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality

What makes a lure great? It’s all in the details.

What Makes a Lure Better:
  • Realistic Colors: Lures that look like the real food fish eat do better.
  • Good Action: A lure that wiggles and moves in the water attracts fish.
  • Durability: Lures that last through many catches are a win.
  • Added Scents: Some fish are attracted to certain smells.
What Can Make a Lure Worse:
  • Cheap Plastic: If the plastic is too stiff or tears easily, it won’t last.
  • Bad Colors: Unnatural colors might scare fish away.
  • Poor Molds: Molds that don’t create clean shapes make ugly lures.
  • Lack of Detail: Lures without fins or tails might not look appealing.

4. User Experience and Use Cases

Making soft plastic lures is a rewarding experience. It’s a great way to spend an afternoon. You can make lures for specific types of fishing. Are you fishing for bass? Make them a certain size and color. Do you want to catch trout? Try smaller, more natural-looking lures. Kids can even join in on the fun with adult supervision. It teaches them patience and creativity. You can save money too, by making your own lures instead of buying expensive ones.

Using your homemade lures is the best part. You’ll feel proud when a fish bites your creation. It’s a skill that can improve your fishing trips significantly.


Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Q: What is a soft plastic lure making kit?

A: It’s a box of supplies that helps you create your own soft plastic fishing lures at home.

Q: Is making soft plastic lures difficult?

A: Not at all! Kits are made for beginners, and the instructions are usually very clear.

Q: What kind of plastic is used?

A: It’s a special, non-toxic plastic that melts at a low temperature.

Q: Do I need special tools?

A: You’ll need a heat source like a microwave or pouring pot, and safety gloves. Most kits include the rest.

Q: Can I make different types of lures?

A: Yes, kits come with different molds for various lure shapes like worms, crawfish, and more.

Q: How long does it take to make one lure?

A: It usually takes about 10-20 minutes per lure, including melting and cooling.

Q: Are the materials safe?

A: Yes, the plastics are designed to be safe when used with the provided instructions and safety gear.

Q: Can I add my own scents or colors?

A: Some kits let you add extra scents or glitter. You can often find separate colorants too.

Q: What’s the best way to store homemade lures?

A: Store them in a cool, dry place. Some plastics can melt together if stored in heat.

Q: Can children use these kits?

A: Yes, with adult supervision. Hot plastic requires careful handling.

In conclusion, every product has unique features and benefits. We hope this review helps you decide if it meets your needs. An informed choice ensures the best experience.

If you have any questions or feedback, please share them in the comments. Your input helps everyone. Thank you for reading.

Leave a Comment